Sunday, October 17, 2010

Mammography Debate - When to Start Screening

At what age is it recommended for a woman to start routine mammograms:
A. 40 years old
B. 50 years old
C. Neither A or B
D. Both A and B.

Until last year, there was a uniform recommendation in the United States for women to start routine mammography for breast cancer screening at the age of 40 and then repeat every 1-2 years. However recently the US Preventive services Task Force (USPSTF) has issued new recommendations to start routine mammography screening at age 50, to repeat mammograms every 2 years between ages 50 - 74, and to end screening at age 74.

This recommendation is controversial. As a result there has been some confusion for both patients and physicians as to when a woman should consider getting her mammograms.

The USPSTF made their recommendation based on a review of published evidence of the efficacy of screening in lowering breast cancer mortality rates. These studies were identified through Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials and Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, MEDLINE January 2001 to December 2008. The reviewers found that film mammography is associated with reduced breast cancer mortality rates, especially in women 50 to 74 years old. Women aged 60 - 69 may have the greatest benefit. For women aged 40 to 49 years there was a 15% decrease in mortality.

However a new study from Sweden reports that mammography screening in women aged 40-49 years old showed a much greater reduction in mortality from breast cancer than has been previously reported. This data showed a 29% reduction in breast cancer mortality in this age group when screening was done. In this large study, more than 1 million women were involved, and they were monitored for 16 years. This study was done because of differences in counties in Sweden. Initially in 1986 Sweden targeted women aged 50 - 69 years but left it up to individual counties to determine if women 40 - 49 years old should be screened. About half of the counties invited women aged 40 - 49 years old to undergo screening and half did not. During the follow up period between 1986 - 2005, there were 619 deaths from breast cancer in women ho had been invited for screening, and 1205 deaths in women who had not undergone screening.

Currently in the U.S., most organizations recommend yearly mammograms beginning at age 40, including the American Cancer Society, the National Comprehensive Cancer Network, the American Medical Association, and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. It is only the USSPTF that does not recommend regular mammography in the 40 - 49 year age group.

For women between 40 - 49, it is best to speak with your physician. The decision may need to be made on an individualized basis. If a woman is considered to be at higher risk for breast cancer then an earlier mammography screening should be considered.

Answer - D.

Other related topics:

13 comments:

Omid said...

We were missing you here:)

Dr. Taraneh Razavi said...

Thank you Omid jan for such a gentle reminder of my absence from the blog. I know it's been a while since I've written regular blogs and I have lots of excuses, but mainly it was because writing blogs involves too much sitting time. But I finally found a way to type and walk at the same time. I stick the feet of my surgical tray under the treadmill and raise the tray to where it's high enough to write on so I have a table to write on while I walk. Now I can get work and exercise done. I will have to send a picture and do a blog on just this technique. I have to practice what I preach you know :)

Edwin said...

u have adroit archive of writing..and is articulate...like reading the postings..

mammo said...

this is a very good debate about mammography and the best one which i read

hajarwan said...

Hi,
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

Best of luck to you!

Cheers,
New Delhi Budget Hotel
News Engine
Google Adsense

Ireland said...

I must say, youve got one of the best blogs Ive seen in a long time. What I wouldnt give to be able to create a blog thats as interesting as this. I guess Ill just have to keep reading yours and hope that one day I can write on a subject with as much knowledge as youve got on this one!

Murali.Marimekala said...

I really liked your blog..has good information Dr.

Australia said...

Informative posts, I am a huge fan of your site, keep up the well written work, and I will be a regular visitor for a very long time.

Anonymous said...

به شما افتخار می کنیم.یک ایرانی

LT8E said...

Dr Razavi,
This is perfect! I would love to do a rotation with you. Preventive medicine and patient education are two top interests of mine. Perhaps, in exchange for time spent with you I can offer my leg work to review your literature for your articles/blog posts - this may save you some time and be able to disseminate more sage advice to your audience. Thank you for your contribution to de-mything the misinformation out there!

Panic Away said...

The importance of having a mammogram done cannot be emphasized enough. As the data shows, it does greatly reduce the mortality rate. Thank you for this highly informative article.

jennifer said...

Thank you for the info

pawljohn said...

very interesting article although some of them I did not understand much. anyway hope there will be more articles like this from you. thank a lot